Will the recession increase “haste and paste” journalism culture?

by Tim 3/12/2009 5:44:00 PM
Media commentator Roy Greenslade wrote yesterday that the “overwhelming majority of (freesheets) publish pseudo-journalism”. Indeed, the last issue of Metrica’s PR Industry Benchmarking report (Metrica Numbers) suggested there was evidence of journalists copying and pasting PR copy verbatim.

 

With newspaper readerships in decline and a recession in tow, the pressure on journalists at all levels will only increase. Fewer staff and the demand on those remaining to produce ever more copy, according to some, threatens the editorial integrity of journalism.

 

According to Greenslade this not only threatens to reduce the integrity of journalism, but also the accountability of local government as regional newspapers play an integral role in holding local politicians to account.

This could manifest itself with under-pressure journalists at regional titles publishing articles based on press releases without fully validating the newsworthiness of the issue.

However, just because media content is often generated by PR doesn’t mean it is dishonest. Beth McLoughlin, News Editor at Now Magazine comments that “just because a story is generated by someone with an agenda doesn’t mean that it isn’t worthwhile, or that with the right checks, can’t have journalistic integrity by the time it is published.”

If a political party tries to sell in a story criticising a rival party to a regional newspaper, it clearly has a biased agenda. That does not mean the facts they quote are untrue and nor does it strip the story of value.

I’m sure freesheets will continue to be part of the fabric of our local communities. There is still a demand for what Greenslade calls “commercial rather than journalistic products.” People will still want to know about local news or to find local handymen. All newspapers are commercial operations - that is why the Mail on Sunday gives out free DVDs or The Guardian has given away scores of wall charts. The business model of all newspapers requires them to raise revenue from advertising.

Greenslade’s Evening Standard article which covered our Metrica Numbers research last year quoted Yell’s Susannah Finn as saying: “We may see the occasional case of lazy journalism but for the most part the press is simply working under the pressure of too little time.”

Likewise an article in The Independent covered the emergent “haste and paste” trend identified by Metrica Numbers: “High message delivery and spokespeople mentions suggest the emergence of a copy and paste publishing trend in online media” – Greenslade suggests that this culture has been prevalent in local freesheets.

I will be interested to note from our ongoing research whether the recession means our clients are more able to get their messages across than previously. If newspapers cut back on journalist numbers, those left behind will be under even more pressure to fall into “haste and paste.”

Comments

3/13/2009 11:11:20 AM

Essentially it will all come down to consumers - and whether they will be happy with haste-and-paste in free sheets, or wish to pay for something they consider will give them more context and informed opinion etc.

It's ironic that quality journalism might benefit in the long term from the move to digital formats and aggregation - when you use RSS, for example, and see 10 people all covering the same story, you definitely start to notice qualitative differences.

In addition, the social recommendation tools becoming more prevalent also increasingly put a pressure on those sharing content to distribute relevant and interesting content to protect their own individual reputation, which will hopefully encourage greater quality.

At the moment we're in a real transition phase, but the move to journalists as curators and aggregators will have interesting implications for how cut-and-paste material might be presented.

Dan Thornton gb

3/16/2009 6:31:18 PM

Hi Dan

Many thanks for taking the time to stop by and comment. I very much agree with you that the consumer will be king. You are right to say that RSS feeds mean it is both easy to spot the difference in quality from different sources and also that spotting examples of "haste and paste" subsequently becomes even easier when looking at a feed on a single topic. One can very easily see who is using original content and who is not.

Print media has been feeling the pinch for several years and I expect that to continue. Those that adapt, offering customisable solutions, embracing open source technology, like The New York Times and The Guardian are well placed to ride out the storm. At a local level, content has to be relevant and appealing to readers.

As you say, the media landscape is undergoing many changes at the moment and it isn't yet clear what will be left. I'm interested by the concept of journalists as curators. Online content allows readers to see what sources a journalist might have used to influence their writing, something print media cannot offer. I think this offers an exciting opportunity for journalists to steer their readership towards even more relevant and interesting reading.

Thanks again and keep in touch.

Tim

Tim Mc gb

Add comment


 

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.0.0

About Measurement Matters

A blog about media analysis & evaluation, PR planning, PR measurement and marketing measurement in general.

follow Metrica for media evaluation updates

Our 5 latest tweets:
The remote server returned an error: (401) Unauthorized.
Follow us on Twitter
Add to Technorati Favorites
<

Calendar

<<  September 2010  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
303112345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930123
45678910

View posts in large calendar

Recent comments

Tags

Login

Sign in

Business
Blogging Fusion
Blog Directory
Public Relations Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
blog directory
Blog Flux Directory
British Blogs
Wil's Domain Weblog
Dmegs Directory
Blog Directory
Business blogs
BlogDir
blogburst logo
Blog Directory
Top Spots Links
See blogs and businesses for United Kingdom