Social media - backlash or reality check?

by Richard Bagnall 3/11/2009 7:51:00 PM

While killing an hour or two down the rabbit hole of social media last weekend, I came across an interesting post to share with Measurement Matters' readers.  In "Web 2.0 Weenies and Bullshit Social Media Economics", Michael Gray argues forcefully (and entertainingly) that if you're not making real money out of your social media efforts and activities, then you're totally wasting your time. 

It's a well written opinion piece, the basic tenet of which I totally agree with - particularly this quote:

"Social media is filled with false gods and idols, who try to sell you their own “secret sauce” in get rich quick schemes..." 

To back up his point, he highlights the fact that Robert Scoble (as he describes him, one of the 'poster boys' of social media) has recently left FastCompany.TV.  I wouldn't agree with his use of the term 'fired' though, and I have no doubt the Scobleizer has some exciting new venture up his sleeve - which is of course ignoring the fact that his cheery mugshot is still peering out from the home page of FastCompany's site.  I'll certainly still be following his tweets avidly wherever he ends up.

The fact remains that these days most of us in the commercial world are under ever greater time pressures.  Organisations are cutting back and resourcing levels are often one of the first things to suffer.  If this scenario sounds familiar, more than ever you need to be asking yourself whether the time you spend listening, researching and participating on social media is brining you and your organisation real benefits.  And the real benefits shouldn't be measured in terms of numbers of followers, @replies, page views of your website or blog etc, but proper 'tangible' outcome measures focussing on monetising your time and developing your value to the business.

We're often asked by our clients to help them understand what's going on out there that matters, what doesn't, what can, and should be done about it, what the best approach to do this might be, and then what has been the ROI on their PR efforts.  Our advice is always based around this simple premise which holds as true for traditional media evaluation as it does for social media measurement - one size does not fit all.  Different blogs, sites, networks, people etc matter to different organisations. An approach that works for one company may not work for your company. Don't be afraid to make mistakes.  And make sure that you remain focussed on aligning your organisations benefits with your PR and social media outreach objectives.

Into this tough economic climate the vibrant and exponential world of social media has emerged.  The challenge to all of us is to keep it real - to make it work for our specific needs and to avoid the tempting honey traps that run the risk of draining so much of our precious time.  

If you have some tips on how you remain focus, we would love you to share them with us here.

Comments

3/12/2009 1:43:16 PM

It's hard to know where to begin debunking Michael Gray's shrill, incendiary and short-sighted post.

All I will say is this: a social media strategy (please note that I did not say "campaign") is not a silver bullet to cure all that ails you. It will not REPLACE whatever marketing or PR you are already doing. It is additive. It does require work and time and effort. GASP! Oh, no! When did we all become so work averse?

Can it be difficult to measure? Sure. But how do you measure the return on a round of golf with a client? Dinner? Cocktail party? A birthday phone call? Why do those questions never get asked? Yet that has been the traditional way of "social networking" since time immemorial.

It takes time, it's not free, it may not work- just like ALL marketing and PR. And, you're quite right, one size does not fit all.

The benefits are numerous and in evidence all across the business landscape. You would have to make a deliberate effort to NOT notice. And, apparently, many have done just that.

Matthew Chamberlin us

3/12/2009 4:29:24 PM

Hi Matthew, great comments! We couldn't agree more with you.

Social media strategies should be seen as another tool in the box and certainly shouldn't replace any of the other marketing disciplines. And you're also right that because they can't always be easily measured (as you say like a round of golf) or have one number applied to them, doesn't mean that you shouldn't do it.

Thanks for stopping by Measurement Matters.

Richard gb

3/16/2009 6:06:08 PM

A recent Forrester survey revelas that social media marketing budgets are largely recession proof. A good PPT slide that shows the 'proof' is in the (social media) pudding:

www.flickr.com/photos/jeremiah_owyang/3359292933/

Thane gb

Add comment


 

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.0.0

About Measurement Matters

A blog about media analysis & evaluation, PR planning, PR measurement and marketing measurement in general.

follow Metrica for media evaluation updates

Our 5 latest tweets:
The remote server returned an error: (401) Unauthorized.
Follow us on Twitter
Add to Technorati Favorites
<

Calendar

<<  September 2010  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
303112345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930123
45678910

View posts in large calendar

Recent comments

Tags

Login

Sign in

Business
Blogging Fusion
Blog Directory
Public Relations Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
blog directory
Blog Flux Directory
British Blogs
Wil's Domain Weblog
Dmegs Directory
Blog Directory
Business blogs
BlogDir
blogburst logo
Blog Directory
Top Spots Links
See blogs and businesses for United Kingdom