Looking into my crystal ball...

by Edward Kitchingman 12/22/2008 2:26:00 PM

So 08 has brought us Measurement Matters, Sachsgate and a declining economy, but what’s in store for us in 09. Here are my 3 tips - feel free to disagree

 1)  For cost reasons there will be a dramatic increase in the number of publications moving towards online only content. December has already brought the closure of more local newspapers, with Newsquest's announcement it was cutting 11 of its titles. A recent report by Deloitte titled ‘Stop the presses: print in peril’ predicted that the newspaper and magazine industry could be “decimated” with falling advertising rates, increasing costs and a badly peforming economy.  

As Howard Davies, co-author of the report, told the Financial Times “This is a downward spiral. It has already become quite difficult for print publishers, but it is going to get much worse."

The cheaper online platform offers a viable business solution. There is certainly now the potential consumers, according to Ofcom over half of UK households now have broadband and with the advent of mobile internet this will only grow. Yes, as with anything in the future when nothing is concrete, there will be much hand wringing about the uncertainty of profit and readership, but, I think, there are reasons to be hopeful.  

The recent Forrester Research report noted that trust, and (in my mind, anyway) a motivating factor for continuing consumer loyalty, for print newspapers in America is considerably higher than a personal blog. Surely this trust, and previous brand recognition that established titles have, can successfully crossover on the internet. Indeed, squeeze out the personal bloggers who have stolen a march on them. It might take a brave publisher and time, but as Gary Andrews notes in his blog:

 “even if it is a desperate last throw of the dice, what does a paper have to lose if it tries it? Not that I’d want to see papers disappear from their communities, but if it’s a choice between online-only news and no news at all…” I expect current market conditions might well force the publishers hand sooner than some of us think.     

 2)  Return on Investment metrics will replace Advertising Value Equivalent as the PR industry’s go to figure- maybe wishful think, but it makes sense, doesn’t it?

It’s long been a tarnished metric talked about previously on this blogHowever, if those posts didn’t convince you maybe the following will. It’s a figure that will not make your PR look good. AVE figures are going to go down. So for those of you who benchmark their campaigns success by AVE there could be some potentially tricky boardroom questions.

As the Deloitte report noted, advertising revenues may fall up to 20% and with another report in The Guardian suggesting UK internet ad spend growth will be cut by more than 50% next year. Logic would suggest the need for PR teams to pre-empt this and switch to another boardroom friendly metric like cost per thousand reached. This ROI metric presents a clear and transparent number that can and does give a figure that shows the value of PR- particularly important given this current economic climate.  

3)   Liverpool to win the Premiership. But maybe that’s more of a personal wish…  

Happy Xmas Everyone!

Comments

12/23/2008 9:56:11 AM

Russ Stanton, the Los Angles Times editor, recently remarked that its "Web site revenue now exceeds its editorial payroll costs". Digital now more than covers the entire editorial costs of a massive newspaper. Jeff Jarvis has recently blogged on this development. And with the bankruptcy facing the Tribune Co., owners of the LA Times, the viability of the Web-based journalistic business is probably receiving more attention inside and outside of the newsroom by current media owners.

As for Liverpool and how you now follow your team, think about how... and how often... we source sports news. Crystal balls remain but the digital dimension of being a fan has transformed how we keep informed about everything from Torres' injury recovery to the Super Bowl.

Thane gb

12/23/2008 12:39:59 PM

Excellent and informative article, thanks Ed. I attended a doo last week, where the Daily Telegraph's editor said that they expect to loose £30m of advertising in 2009....

Bob gb

12/23/2008 12:49:08 PM

I look at this more from an advertising revenue perspective and also from a business to business and industry to industry scenario.

Lots of industries are already geared up to online content due to the very nature of the products and services that they provide. For instance the electrical industry is far more switched onto the virtues of advertising online than more traditional manufacturing industries. Working in the kitchen industry for instance, it is very traditional- our trade publication is still well received and the first point advertisers will go to in times of economic crisis.

Decision makers still need something tangible and a lot are suprisingly not as computer-savvy as you might think.

There is no doubt that with the rising price of printing costs publishers are going to come under strain- ways round this include changing paper weight, bringing reproduction in house and changing the nature of printing in general. Publications go in and out of busniess all the time and suprisingly even in the last 6 months we have had new competitive media launched against us.

There are also two important roles to consider for the advertiser themselves and marketing agencies. We are constantly being told that newspaper and magazine advertising spend will decrease next year with online, digital and direct marketing reaping rewards. However advertisers need to support the industry trade magazines that they love to receive each week, month on their desks.

Buying agencies and marketers on the other hand are now under more scrutiny to perform than ever. Many will find it hard to convince clients to go online and digital in the more tradiional industries and many have already lost accounts with companies choosing to market internally thus saving costs. Companies are also deciding to skip advertising altogether and use their already existing databases to direct mail.

PR is can't always be measured in a transparent way as it is usually compared to advertisijng SCC rates and typical rate card page rates. Hardly any magazines can now command these prices so price comparison is already floored. There is also the famous saying whereby Editorial tells and advertisements sell. With free PR it is all about the percieved value a client is getting. A PR campaign is floored if it judges success on cost per thousand reached as it is more about the quality of the circulation. A smaller niche circulation will always produce a better reader response than a more generic circulation whereby an advertisers products are peripheral.

Those that do advertise and continue to brand to the consumer will be the ones with their heads above the water when everything is okay again. Marketing week recently reported that home interest magazines are being more widely read than ever due to the downturn in housing. People are improving instead of moving pardon the cliche!

Maybe I am the eternal optimist but every cloud.....the credit crunch could be the best thing that has ever happened for the newspaer and magazine industries making them more efficient, more streamlined and more effective than ever. There are far too many lazy publishers out there and they are now getting found out.

Liverpool have more competition than newspapers! Especially with the resurgence of a certain North London side that play in white....



Will Squeaky gb

12/24/2008 10:10:15 AM

Will, I agree. I think there are far too many 'lazy' publishers. Part of the streamlining process that you mention will be a choice for loss making publishers to continue with a loss making format, or to try something new-online only content.

With regards to SCC rates and typical rate cards, it illustrates again, the problem, of AVEs. I offered cost per thousand, as it by-passes AVE all together, while also offering a value of PR metric people at board level love. I agree, again, with the idea of niche audiences, which is why we also include in our methodology the opportunity the for clients to see how much of their coverage has reached its target audiences.

Ed gb

12/29/2008 9:46:53 AM

I think that 2009 will be interesting for a nmber of different businesses, especially retail have had a bad Christmas and discounting heavily

Business-Blog gb

1/1/2009 1:39:20 AM

Great article. Very informative. I hope 2009 brings some changes with it in the economy. Thanks for your useful tips.

Speed Dating us

Add comment


 

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.0.0

About Measurement Matters

A blog about media analysis & evaluation, PR planning, PR measurement and marketing measurement in general.

follow Metrica for media evaluation updates

Our 5 latest tweets:
The remote server returned an error: (401) Unauthorized.
Follow us on Twitter
Add to Technorati Favorites
<

Calendar

<<  September 2010  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
303112345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930123
45678910

View posts in large calendar

Recent comments

Tags

Login

Sign in

Business
Blogging Fusion
Blog Directory
Public Relations Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
blog directory
Blog Flux Directory
British Blogs
Wil's Domain Weblog
Dmegs Directory
Blog Directory
Business blogs
BlogDir
blogburst logo
Blog Directory
Top Spots Links
See blogs and businesses for United Kingdom